Maybe I was just in a bad mood today, but Seth Fein's comments about the Burnham Mansion in Smile Politely today saddened me greatly. Here are my thoughts.
Dear Seth,
I think you know that I love you dearly, and am incredibly supportive, and admiring, of your creative efforts, and your undying love for this town. And you and I have disagreed, with, I believe, respect, about our views on the issue of the Burnham Mansion and the renovation and expansion of Central High School. However, I am deeply saddened and disheartened by your comments about the Burnham Mansion saga, as you called it, in Smile Politely today.
First, I’m not sure why activists was in quotes. Was this to imply that they were not activists, bad activists, fake activists, or just activists you didn’t agree with? I truly do not understand that, but perhaps it is just an editing issue that doesn’t matter. More importantly, I don’t understand the reference to slave quarters. Again, I truly, truly just don’t understand. Can you explain? The Burnham house was built several decades after Emancipation. Is this a reference to servant’s quarters? I can not comprehend somehow equating this house with slavery. If you want to equate every house built in the 19th century with that, well, I got nothing…..as that would perhaps include the house that you are restoring, or so, so many structures throughout this community and this country.
You refer to adults acting as toddlers after it was announced that the house would indeed be destroyed. I agree wholeheartedly. I saw people on BOTH sides saying things that I thought were completely lacking in basic respect and common courtesy---about the issues, and particularly about the people involved. I abhorred some of the comments made about people working incredibly hard (such as Chris Kloeppel and Amy Armstrong….Amy, whom I consider a beloved personal friend), even though I happened to disagree with them. However, I also abhorred some of the equally ignorant and thoughtless comments that I heard over and over and over again about the importance of the Burnham House and those that happened to see its value and importance in this community, and throughout this nation.
Further, to imply that everyone that supported the preservation of the Burnham Mansion did not see the value of an expanded, restored and functional Central High School, is again short sighted and regrettably insulting. I supported the referendum. I saw the need. I have one son that recently graduated, and one son still attending Central. And every day I drive down Church Street to my home and I see the buildings being torn down one by one. And I could sorrowfully accept the destruction of every one of those EXCEPT the Burnham Mansion.
I applaud that you are preserving your house. I am, if not preserving, doing my damndest to sustain, an old house which I love dearly...and I believe the restoration and preservation of vernacular architecture is vital and important, in this community and beyond. However, the Burnham House was not vernacular, it was a highly significant structure, both architecturally and historically. The historic significance was important to this community, but the architectural significance was important to this country. Yes, COUNTRY, not county, not town, not community. However much I will be pleased to see a healthy and functional Central High School, I will always see the destruction of this building as an embarrassment and a disgrace. It did not have to be EITHER the Burnham or the School. As you referenced, creatively, patience, and a sense of the role of the history IN education, could have prevailed. The Burnham Mansion, without question, was built by an internationally important architect, and was one of the few remaining residential buildings by the renowned architect Daniel Burnham, who is most famous for his 1909 Plan of Chicago, for overseeing the design and construction of the 1893 Columbian Exposition, and for buildings throughout Chicago and beyond.
As Burnham once so presciently said,
Make no little plans; they have no magic to stir men's blood and probably themselves will not be realized. Make big plans; aim high in hope and work, remembering that a noble, logical diagram once recorded will never die, but long after we are gone be a living thing, asserting itself with ever-growing insistency. Remember that our sons and our grandsons are going to do things that would stagger us.
Seth, I remain your friend.
Sadly,
Cynthia

Recent Comments